Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
- (-) Remove and filter and
- (-) Remove polemic, filter polemic,
- concern (15) Apply concern filter
- elect (15) Apply elect filter
- letter (15) Apply letter filter
- matter (15) Apply matter filter
- matters, (15) Apply matters, filter
- polem (15) Apply polem filter
- polit (15) Apply polit filter
- public (15) Apply public filter
Displaying 1 - 12 of 15
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $400
Sold for: $1,375
Including buyer's premium
Letter handwritten and signed by Rabbi "Elazar Menachem Mann Schach", to Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson Av Beit Din of Komemiyut. Bnei Brak, Iyar 1962.
Letter in regard to the soldiers of the Nachal Charedi in Moshav Komemiyut. Rabbi Schach expresses his opinion on the subject in his interesting way, significantly evasive: "Regarding transferring the Nachal to Chazon Yechezkel, I did not give a heter (deeming it permissible) and I did not say anything about this. Just Rabbi Lorincz told me that in this manner… all would be corrected. I told him that I do not know, but if this is the best suggestion, let it be so, but I do not know. Therefore, you cannot rely on me at all in this matter. In my opinion, if you do not want to make this decision, you can suggest that two rabbis come and see the situation from close…I phoned Rabbi Lorincz and told him so and he told me that you have given a definite heter. In any case, I do not know of this and I did not say anything…".
The Nachal Charedi was established in the 1960s by the "Army and Settlement" department of the Tze'irei Agudat Yisrael – movement for Charedi working young men. These men resided in the Charedi Moshav Komemiyut in Chevel Lachish and were employed with agricultural work and in the diamond industry. Near Moshav Komemiyut, a Charedi youth-village was established called Chazon Yechezkel. This letter is a response to the proposal of moving the Nachal HaCharedi young men from Komemiyut to Chazon Yechezkel or someplace else following spiritual problems that arose in the moshav and in the youth-village.
Leaf, approximately 19 cm. Approximately 14 handwritten lines. Good-fair condition, stains and damages to the line with the date, restored.
Letter in regard to the soldiers of the Nachal Charedi in Moshav Komemiyut. Rabbi Schach expresses his opinion on the subject in his interesting way, significantly evasive: "Regarding transferring the Nachal to Chazon Yechezkel, I did not give a heter (deeming it permissible) and I did not say anything about this. Just Rabbi Lorincz told me that in this manner… all would be corrected. I told him that I do not know, but if this is the best suggestion, let it be so, but I do not know. Therefore, you cannot rely on me at all in this matter. In my opinion, if you do not want to make this decision, you can suggest that two rabbis come and see the situation from close…I phoned Rabbi Lorincz and told him so and he told me that you have given a definite heter. In any case, I do not know of this and I did not say anything…".
The Nachal Charedi was established in the 1960s by the "Army and Settlement" department of the Tze'irei Agudat Yisrael – movement for Charedi working young men. These men resided in the Charedi Moshav Komemiyut in Chevel Lachish and were employed with agricultural work and in the diamond industry. Near Moshav Komemiyut, a Charedi youth-village was established called Chazon Yechezkel. This letter is a response to the proposal of moving the Nachal HaCharedi young men from Komemiyut to Chazon Yechezkel or someplace else following spiritual problems that arose in the moshav and in the youth-village.
Leaf, approximately 19 cm. Approximately 14 handwritten lines. Good-fair condition, stains and damages to the line with the date, restored.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $700
Sold for: $1,000
Including buyer's premium
Letter handwritten and signed by Rabbi Ya'akov Yisrael Kanievsky – the Steipler, to Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson Ga'avad of Komemiyut. Bnei Brak, 1962.
In the letter, the Steipler mentions the question regarding Moshav Komemiyut brought to him by Rabbi Shlomo Lorentz. He writes, "From my lowly state, I have not found any heter to permit this, neither from legal authorities nor from fear of stealing. Nevertheless, I also cannot prohibit this, and someone greater shall rule, and I will eliminate myself from resolving this question". On the margin of the letter he adds: "At the time Rabbi Shlomo Lorentz came to me, I saw certain sides of the matter, but after studying the subject, it seems that they do not have a real halachic basis".
The Rabbi of Komemiyut – Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson (1904-1979), used to consult the Chazon Ish and Rabbi Yitzchak Ze'ev of Brisk and the Tshebin Rav on halachic topics which concerned public issues. This letter was written in 1962. Evidently after the death of the Chazon Ish and the Brisker Rav, Rabbi Mendelson sent this question to the Steipler, Rabbi Ya'akov Yisrael Kanievsky (1899-1985) but he refused to rule and referred the question to "someone greater" [apparently referring to the Tshebin Rav whom the Steipler highly esteemed].
Official stationery, 23 cm. Approximately 14 written lines. Good condition.
In the letter, the Steipler mentions the question regarding Moshav Komemiyut brought to him by Rabbi Shlomo Lorentz. He writes, "From my lowly state, I have not found any heter to permit this, neither from legal authorities nor from fear of stealing. Nevertheless, I also cannot prohibit this, and someone greater shall rule, and I will eliminate myself from resolving this question". On the margin of the letter he adds: "At the time Rabbi Shlomo Lorentz came to me, I saw certain sides of the matter, but after studying the subject, it seems that they do not have a real halachic basis".
The Rabbi of Komemiyut – Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson (1904-1979), used to consult the Chazon Ish and Rabbi Yitzchak Ze'ev of Brisk and the Tshebin Rav on halachic topics which concerned public issues. This letter was written in 1962. Evidently after the death of the Chazon Ish and the Brisker Rav, Rabbi Mendelson sent this question to the Steipler, Rabbi Ya'akov Yisrael Kanievsky (1899-1985) but he refused to rule and referred the question to "someone greater" [apparently referring to the Tshebin Rav whom the Steipler highly esteemed].
Official stationery, 23 cm. Approximately 14 written lines. Good condition.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $250
Sold for: $1,250
Including buyer's premium
A letter signed by rabbis of HaEda HaCharedit Beit Din, Rabbi Pinchas Epstein – Av Beit Din, Rabbi Yisrael Yitzchak Halevi Reisman and Rabbi David Jungreis. Jerusalem, Tevet, 1962.
Sent to the Gaon Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson, Rabbi of the Charedi Moshav Komemiyut: "We heard (and saw in national newpapers) that recruitment Nachal in Moshav Amiaz, which startled Yahadut HaTorah, - moved to Moshav Komemiyut". Further in the letter they wonder that despite the fact that Rebbe of Vizhnitz cancelled and closed the Nachal Moshav in Moshav Amiaz, the matter rises again in a Charedi Moshav, a fact staining the name of Charedi Jewery "which Moshav Komemiyut always supports".
They explain their objection, "since except for the matter of recruitment, this is a dangerous step which endangers the Yeshivot, and is an opening for those who wish to find excuses to leave the Yeshivot".
The Nachal Charedi, for Charedi working youngsters, was established in the 1960s, by the "Army and Settlement" department of "Tze'irei Agudat Israel" movement. In 1962 the Nachal recruits settled in Moshav Komemiyut in Lachish region, and were employed in agricultural duties and in the diamond industry. The establishment of Nachal was accompanied by wide public objection on the part of Charedi circles, fearing that this will lead to a spiritual deterioration of the soldiers themselves, and this will lead to the destruction of Yeshivot by the authorities. This dispute returned in the last few years, with the founding of "Gedud Netzach Yehudah", "Shacha"r Kachol" and "Nachal Charedi" when the "Eda Charedit" circles and other groups organized demonstrations against these trends.
Official stationery, 27.5 cm. Fair condition, creases and wear.
Sent to the Gaon Rabbi Binyamin Mendelson, Rabbi of the Charedi Moshav Komemiyut: "We heard (and saw in national newpapers) that recruitment Nachal in Moshav Amiaz, which startled Yahadut HaTorah, - moved to Moshav Komemiyut". Further in the letter they wonder that despite the fact that Rebbe of Vizhnitz cancelled and closed the Nachal Moshav in Moshav Amiaz, the matter rises again in a Charedi Moshav, a fact staining the name of Charedi Jewery "which Moshav Komemiyut always supports".
They explain their objection, "since except for the matter of recruitment, this is a dangerous step which endangers the Yeshivot, and is an opening for those who wish to find excuses to leave the Yeshivot".
The Nachal Charedi, for Charedi working youngsters, was established in the 1960s, by the "Army and Settlement" department of "Tze'irei Agudat Israel" movement. In 1962 the Nachal recruits settled in Moshav Komemiyut in Lachish region, and were employed in agricultural duties and in the diamond industry. The establishment of Nachal was accompanied by wide public objection on the part of Charedi circles, fearing that this will lead to a spiritual deterioration of the soldiers themselves, and this will lead to the destruction of Yeshivot by the authorities. This dispute returned in the last few years, with the founding of "Gedud Netzach Yehudah", "Shacha"r Kachol" and "Nachal Charedi" when the "Eda Charedit" circles and other groups organized demonstrations against these trends.
Official stationery, 27.5 cm. Fair condition, creases and wear.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $1,000
Sold for: $2,375
Including buyer's premium
A collection of letters, concerning the polemic surrounding the marriage of Rabbi Amram Blau with the proselyte Ruth Ben-David – the responsum of Rabbi Amram Blau to the Badatz Eda HaCharedit in Jerusalem about their opposition to his marriage and agitated letters from her to the Ra'avad Rabbi David Jungreis. [Jerusalem, 1965].
• Four large pages of a responsum in the handwriting of Rabbi Amram Blau in which Rabbi Amram explains that no halachic problem exists in his marrying a young woman and he protests the claim that this step diminishes his honor and is a desecration of G-d's name. On the contrary, it is a great mitzvah to draw a proselyte near.
• Letter (in Yiddish) handwritten and signed by Ruth Ben-David to the Ra'avad Rabbi David Jungreis in which she writes about the events and expresses her pain on what is being done to her.
• Another letter (in Yiddish) handwritten and signed by Ruth Ben-David to Rabbi David Jungreis, in which she agitatedly complains that her "blood is being spilled" and she asks if it is permissible to cause such pain to a proselyte!
• Open letter against the pursuit of Rabbi Amram Blau – proclamation (stencil printing), by Rabbi Eliyahu Weinstein.
One of the events that stirred the emotions of the Charedi public in Jerusalem was the polemic surrounding the marriage of Rabbi Amram Blau to the proselyte Ruth Ben-David. Rabbi Amram, who at the time was a widower close to 70 years old was about to marry Ruth Ben-David, a French proselyte who was more than 20 years younger than him. Ben-David was involved in the concealment of the boy Yosse'le Shuchmacher and in smuggling him out of the country. During that time, she became acquainted with the population of the Yishuv HaYashan and she wished to join this closed community, but this led to sharp opposition from the people affiliated with the Niturei Karta and the Eda HaCharedit. The disciples and sons of Rabbi Amram considered his marriage to Ruth Ben-David to be a diminishment of his status. The rabbis of the Eda HaCharedit also opposed his marriage on halachic grounds of the marriage of a young woman to an old man and also fearing that this step would be a desecration of G-d’s name. The Charedi street seethed, notices and proclamations were publicized in the streets of Jerusalem, and the city raged. At the end, after more than half a year of stormy polemic, the two married in Elul 1965. Rabbi Amram was forced to leave his native city of Jerusalem and moved for a while to Bnei Brak. After many years, Ruth Ben-David Blau published her best-seller Shomrei Ha’Ir (Jerusalem 1979) in which she relates this painful episode of her life.
4 handwritten leaves 32 cm + two letters (one is written on two pages), and a proclamation 27-28 cm. Good to good-fair condition.
• Four large pages of a responsum in the handwriting of Rabbi Amram Blau in which Rabbi Amram explains that no halachic problem exists in his marrying a young woman and he protests the claim that this step diminishes his honor and is a desecration of G-d's name. On the contrary, it is a great mitzvah to draw a proselyte near.
• Letter (in Yiddish) handwritten and signed by Ruth Ben-David to the Ra'avad Rabbi David Jungreis in which she writes about the events and expresses her pain on what is being done to her.
• Another letter (in Yiddish) handwritten and signed by Ruth Ben-David to Rabbi David Jungreis, in which she agitatedly complains that her "blood is being spilled" and she asks if it is permissible to cause such pain to a proselyte!
• Open letter against the pursuit of Rabbi Amram Blau – proclamation (stencil printing), by Rabbi Eliyahu Weinstein.
One of the events that stirred the emotions of the Charedi public in Jerusalem was the polemic surrounding the marriage of Rabbi Amram Blau to the proselyte Ruth Ben-David. Rabbi Amram, who at the time was a widower close to 70 years old was about to marry Ruth Ben-David, a French proselyte who was more than 20 years younger than him. Ben-David was involved in the concealment of the boy Yosse'le Shuchmacher and in smuggling him out of the country. During that time, she became acquainted with the population of the Yishuv HaYashan and she wished to join this closed community, but this led to sharp opposition from the people affiliated with the Niturei Karta and the Eda HaCharedit. The disciples and sons of Rabbi Amram considered his marriage to Ruth Ben-David to be a diminishment of his status. The rabbis of the Eda HaCharedit also opposed his marriage on halachic grounds of the marriage of a young woman to an old man and also fearing that this step would be a desecration of G-d’s name. The Charedi street seethed, notices and proclamations were publicized in the streets of Jerusalem, and the city raged. At the end, after more than half a year of stormy polemic, the two married in Elul 1965. Rabbi Amram was forced to leave his native city of Jerusalem and moved for a while to Bnei Brak. After many years, Ruth Ben-David Blau published her best-seller Shomrei Ha’Ir (Jerusalem 1979) in which she relates this painful episode of her life.
4 handwritten leaves 32 cm + two letters (one is written on two pages), and a proclamation 27-28 cm. Good to good-fair condition.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $1,000
Sold for: $3,750
Including buyer's premium
Letter to the management of the Etz Chaim Yeshiva in Jerusalem, signed by 71 rabbis who study in the yeshiva with a request to abstain from hanging the Israeli flag and identifying with the State of Israel on the Day of Independence. Rosh Chodesh Iyar 1954.
"… It is unnecessary to expound upon the great desecration of G-d and of the holy Torah, carried out by the "free" (non-religious) government, which constantly announce that they have no part and parcel of G-d and of his holy Torah. How our hearts ache to see their Day of Independence each year, the Zionist flag waving over the gate of our holy yeshiva, which seemingly demonstrates that our holy yeshiva identifies with this government, and this is a great desecration of G-d… Please have compassion on the honor of G-d and the honor of the Torah and on the pain of the students of the holy yeshiva…".
The letter is signed in the handwriting of 71 yeshiva students. We will note some of the more famous: Rabbi Zvi Michel Heller, Rabbi Shmuel Auerbach [later, head of Ma'alot HaTorah Yeshiva], Rabbi Zerach Efraim Zelaznik, Rabbi Avraham Dov Auerbach, Rabbi Yechiel Matitya Davis, Rabbi Moshe Baruch Levine, Rabbi Yitzchak David Gotfarb, Rabbi Gedalya Neiman [author of Gidulei Shmuel and one of the yeshiva heads], Rabbi Shalom Eisen, Rabbi Nachman David Duvinky, Rabbi Binyamin Ze'ev Prague, Rabbi Sender Freund, Rabbi Avraham Bradky, Rabbi Ze'ev Dov Chechik, Rabbi Yehuda Shapira [lather, head of Kollel Chazon Ish], Rabbi Avraham Chaim Brimm, Rabbi Moshe Yehoshua Landau, and other many important figures.
Leaf 28 cm. [2] written pages. Good-fair condition, wear and tears to margins and to paper folds.
"… It is unnecessary to expound upon the great desecration of G-d and of the holy Torah, carried out by the "free" (non-religious) government, which constantly announce that they have no part and parcel of G-d and of his holy Torah. How our hearts ache to see their Day of Independence each year, the Zionist flag waving over the gate of our holy yeshiva, which seemingly demonstrates that our holy yeshiva identifies with this government, and this is a great desecration of G-d… Please have compassion on the honor of G-d and the honor of the Torah and on the pain of the students of the holy yeshiva…".
The letter is signed in the handwriting of 71 yeshiva students. We will note some of the more famous: Rabbi Zvi Michel Heller, Rabbi Shmuel Auerbach [later, head of Ma'alot HaTorah Yeshiva], Rabbi Zerach Efraim Zelaznik, Rabbi Avraham Dov Auerbach, Rabbi Yechiel Matitya Davis, Rabbi Moshe Baruch Levine, Rabbi Yitzchak David Gotfarb, Rabbi Gedalya Neiman [author of Gidulei Shmuel and one of the yeshiva heads], Rabbi Shalom Eisen, Rabbi Nachman David Duvinky, Rabbi Binyamin Ze'ev Prague, Rabbi Sender Freund, Rabbi Avraham Bradky, Rabbi Ze'ev Dov Chechik, Rabbi Yehuda Shapira [lather, head of Kollel Chazon Ish], Rabbi Avraham Chaim Brimm, Rabbi Moshe Yehoshua Landau, and other many important figures.
Leaf 28 cm. [2] written pages. Good-fair condition, wear and tears to margins and to paper folds.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $900
Sold for: $1,750
Including buyer's premium
Letter "Revealing the Torah Opinion of the USA Union of Rabbis", handwritten and signed by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, president of the Union of Rabbis. New York, [1973].
Written at the time the decision was rendered to shorten Rabbi Unterman's term as Chief Rabbi of Israel to only ten years [a political move by Rabbi Goren's friends to dismiss the Chief Rabbis Rabbi Isser Yehuda Unterman and Rabbi Yitzchak Nissim]. In 1973, new elections were conducted in which Rabbi Shlomo Goren and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef were elected as Chief Rabbis of Israel.
Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, who opposed the dismissal of Rabbi Isser Yehuda Unterman and the appointment of Rabbi Goren, wrote the ruling in this open letter: "The subject of the Jewish rabbinate all over the world, is a matter of authority which according to Torah law is irrevocable all his life… Therefore, G-d forbid, considering the dismissal of R' Isser Yehuda Unterman from the position of Chief Rabbi of Eretz Yisrael and to appoint someone else in his stead. [I], who writes and signs for the sake of truth and peace – Moshe Feinstein, President".
Official stationery of the "The Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the United States and Canada". 8 handwritten lines. 28 cm. Good condition. Moisture damages and folding marks.
Written at the time the decision was rendered to shorten Rabbi Unterman's term as Chief Rabbi of Israel to only ten years [a political move by Rabbi Goren's friends to dismiss the Chief Rabbis Rabbi Isser Yehuda Unterman and Rabbi Yitzchak Nissim]. In 1973, new elections were conducted in which Rabbi Shlomo Goren and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef were elected as Chief Rabbis of Israel.
Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, who opposed the dismissal of Rabbi Isser Yehuda Unterman and the appointment of Rabbi Goren, wrote the ruling in this open letter: "The subject of the Jewish rabbinate all over the world, is a matter of authority which according to Torah law is irrevocable all his life… Therefore, G-d forbid, considering the dismissal of R' Isser Yehuda Unterman from the position of Chief Rabbi of Eretz Yisrael and to appoint someone else in his stead. [I], who writes and signs for the sake of truth and peace – Moshe Feinstein, President".
Official stationery of the "The Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the United States and Canada". 8 handwritten lines. 28 cm. Good condition. Moisture damages and folding marks.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $250
Unsold
Protocol of the agreement among the members of the various factions of Agudat Yisrael concerning the division of representatives and members of the party management for the Agudat Yisrael list to the sixth Knesset. Av 1965.
The elections to the sixth Knesset took place in November 1965. Present at the meeting were: Rabbi Moshe Porush and his son Rabbi Menachem, Rabbi Shmuel Shzadrovsky, Rabbi Shlomo Lorintz, Rabbi Zelig Steinmetz, Rabbi Yitzchak Meir, Rabbi Y.M. Avramowitz, Rabbi S.Y. Gross, Rabbi Shimon Siroka, etc. One of the matters discussed in the agreement is the resignation of the fifth representative of the list in favor of the sixth representative, a member of the “central faction” of Ger Chassidim, if ”the head of the movement, Rabbi Yitzchak Meir Levine decides to resign from the Knesset”.
In Section 8 of the protocol is a decision to set up a disciplinary committee “to assert authority on the movement’s newspapers, including: HaModia, Digleinu, Beit Ya’akov and the rest of the publications linked indirectly or directly with the movement”.
Signatures of Rabbi Shzadrovitsky, Rabbi Shimo Siroka and Rabbi S.Y. Gross.
Thin paper, 32 cm. typewritten with handwritten corrections, additions and signatures. Fair condition, wear to top of leaf.
The elections to the sixth Knesset took place in November 1965. Present at the meeting were: Rabbi Moshe Porush and his son Rabbi Menachem, Rabbi Shmuel Shzadrovsky, Rabbi Shlomo Lorintz, Rabbi Zelig Steinmetz, Rabbi Yitzchak Meir, Rabbi Y.M. Avramowitz, Rabbi S.Y. Gross, Rabbi Shimon Siroka, etc. One of the matters discussed in the agreement is the resignation of the fifth representative of the list in favor of the sixth representative, a member of the “central faction” of Ger Chassidim, if ”the head of the movement, Rabbi Yitzchak Meir Levine decides to resign from the Knesset”.
In Section 8 of the protocol is a decision to set up a disciplinary committee “to assert authority on the movement’s newspapers, including: HaModia, Digleinu, Beit Ya’akov and the rest of the publications linked indirectly or directly with the movement”.
Signatures of Rabbi Shzadrovitsky, Rabbi Shimo Siroka and Rabbi S.Y. Gross.
Thin paper, 32 cm. typewritten with handwritten corrections, additions and signatures. Fair condition, wear to top of leaf.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $3,000
Unsold
Letter by Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson of Lubavitch-Chabad to Rabbi Yisrael Grossman of Jerusalem. Brooklyn, Tishrei 1965.
Letter on various topics connected to the elections to the Israeli Knesset.
Official stationery, typewritten, with the Rebbe's signature and corrections in his handwriting.
Leaf, 27 cm. Good condition, folding marks.
Unknown letter, apparently unprinted.
Letter on various topics connected to the elections to the Israeli Knesset.
Official stationery, typewritten, with the Rebbe's signature and corrections in his handwriting.
Leaf, 27 cm. Good condition, folding marks.
Unknown letter, apparently unprinted.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $3,000
Unsold
Letter by Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson of Lubabitch-Chabad, concerning the elections to the Israeli Knesset, to Yitzchak Meir HaCohen [Levine] – Minister of Welfare. Brooklyn, 1951.
Official stationery, typewritten with the Rebbe's signature, and the words "Respectfully" and "L'Hatzlacha" in his handwriting.
A letter about establishing a joint religious front. The Rebbe expresses his opinion concerning participation in elections to the Knesset: “As I have told you… I have written to the inhabitants of the Holy Land my opinion about participation in the election, which obligate each and every man and woman to participate in the election and to vote for the more Charedi lists and to convince others to do so…”.
Leaf, 24 cm. Good condition, folding marks, file holes and tears to margins.
Official stationery, typewritten with the Rebbe's signature, and the words "Respectfully" and "L'Hatzlacha" in his handwriting.
A letter about establishing a joint religious front. The Rebbe expresses his opinion concerning participation in elections to the Knesset: “As I have told you… I have written to the inhabitants of the Holy Land my opinion about participation in the election, which obligate each and every man and woman to participate in the election and to vote for the more Charedi lists and to convince others to do so…”.
Leaf, 24 cm. Good condition, folding marks, file holes and tears to margins.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $3,000
Sold for: $8,750
Including buyer's premium
Letter handwritten and signed by Rabbi Shach head of Ponevezh Yeshiva, about his attitude towards Chassidim and Rebbes. Bnei Brak, Cheshvan 1988.
Sent to "The rebbe Rahatz in Jerusalem" – before the elections to the Knesset in the autumn of 1988, at the time Rabbi Shach founded the Degel HaTorah movement [after Agudat Yisrael refused to accept the opinion of the heads of yeshivot and Lithuanian Torah leaders – especially Related to the Messiac movement of Chabad Chassidim].
He writes as follows: "In continuation of our conversation yesterday, I was really shocked to hear of the slander and falsehood told about me that I have spoken or done something, G-d forbid, against Chassidim and their leaders…This is a lowly defamation and a coarse falsehood to say that I oppose Chassidim. I have already said that I truly do not have and never had anything against Chassidism or Chassidim. It is well-known that thousands of Chassidic students studied and are studying at present in our holy yeshiva. I have never treated them differently in any way from any other students – I am sorry that the word "sect" that I used in my opposition to Chabad Chassidism hurt the Chassidim, but G-d forbid, I did not mean Chassidim in general, whom I know to be G-d-fearing and complete in Torah and mitzvah observance... On the contrary, I cannot imagine the way our generation would look without Chassidism and Chassidim and their lofty activities for Torah and Judaism, with their characteristic beloved warmth, especially the rebbes and their special yeshivot which have an important place in the Torah world…”.
This letter came from the home of the Spinka-Zhydachiv, Rebbe Alter Eliezer Kahane (1937-2009), a holy tsaddik and an outstanding Jerusalem Torah scholar - See Item 439 - who was hurt during the
dispute which developed between Chassidim and Jews of Lithuanian tradition during that election campaign and he traveled to Bnei Brak to speak with Rabbi Shach on this matter. Rabbi Shach heard his painful plaints and he knew no rest all night. The next day, he wrote this letter and sent it with a special messenger who brought the home of Rebbe Alter Kahane in Jerusalem. [Interestingly, he did not explicitly write the name of the recipient, the Rebbe, in the letter. Perhaps he was concerned lest this lead to additional polemic and dispute].
Official stationery, 25 cm. Approximately 19 handwritten lines. Very-good condition, folding marks. + the original envelope in which the letter arrived.
Sent to "The rebbe Rahatz in Jerusalem" – before the elections to the Knesset in the autumn of 1988, at the time Rabbi Shach founded the Degel HaTorah movement [after Agudat Yisrael refused to accept the opinion of the heads of yeshivot and Lithuanian Torah leaders – especially Related to the Messiac movement of Chabad Chassidim].
He writes as follows: "In continuation of our conversation yesterday, I was really shocked to hear of the slander and falsehood told about me that I have spoken or done something, G-d forbid, against Chassidim and their leaders…This is a lowly defamation and a coarse falsehood to say that I oppose Chassidim. I have already said that I truly do not have and never had anything against Chassidism or Chassidim. It is well-known that thousands of Chassidic students studied and are studying at present in our holy yeshiva. I have never treated them differently in any way from any other students – I am sorry that the word "sect" that I used in my opposition to Chabad Chassidism hurt the Chassidim, but G-d forbid, I did not mean Chassidim in general, whom I know to be G-d-fearing and complete in Torah and mitzvah observance... On the contrary, I cannot imagine the way our generation would look without Chassidism and Chassidim and their lofty activities for Torah and Judaism, with their characteristic beloved warmth, especially the rebbes and their special yeshivot which have an important place in the Torah world…”.
This letter came from the home of the Spinka-Zhydachiv, Rebbe Alter Eliezer Kahane (1937-2009), a holy tsaddik and an outstanding Jerusalem Torah scholar - See Item 439 - who was hurt during the
dispute which developed between Chassidim and Jews of Lithuanian tradition during that election campaign and he traveled to Bnei Brak to speak with Rabbi Shach on this matter. Rabbi Shach heard his painful plaints and he knew no rest all night. The next day, he wrote this letter and sent it with a special messenger who brought the home of Rebbe Alter Kahane in Jerusalem. [Interestingly, he did not explicitly write the name of the recipient, the Rebbe, in the letter. Perhaps he was concerned lest this lead to additional polemic and dispute].
Official stationery, 25 cm. Approximately 19 handwritten lines. Very-good condition, folding marks. + the original envelope in which the letter arrived.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $5,000
Unsold
A long letter handwritten and signed by Rabbi Ya'akov Yisrael Kanievsky – the Steipler, to Rabbi Shmuel Huminer of Jerusalem. Bnei Brak, 1968.
The letter is about the printing of the Igeret Kodesh pamphlet by the Steipler [discussing the holy conduct of the Jewish home], printed by Rabbi Shmuel Huminer written by an anonymous author, but the introduction hints that the writer is "one of the leading rabbis of these times".
The Steipler writes that the pamphlet is very hurtful to people, "It is now clear that Chassidim who conduct themselves in holiness for several generations are very hurt by this pamphlet and declare that it will harm the peace of their home, G-d forbid, etc.". The Steipler requests that Rabbi Shmuel Huminer bury the pamphlet (in geniza). "If you do not intend to put it in geniza, at least tear out the leaf of introduction, and on Page 7 at the top, erase the words "Letter by one of the leading rabbis of these times", so that the reader will not discern that someone else wrote the pamphlet, but it shall seem as if the publisher edited this letter…".
The polemic regarding the Steipler's opinion on the subject of guiding couples before their marriage on holy conduct of the Jewish home and the comeback of disciples of the Ger Rebbe author of the Beit Yisrael against the publishing of his opinion, is a veiled topic and most of the relevant facts are unknown. Now, this historical letter on this affair has been discovered.
2 leaves, 19.5 cm. Very good condition, folding marks.
Photos of this item are not available.
The letter is about the printing of the Igeret Kodesh pamphlet by the Steipler [discussing the holy conduct of the Jewish home], printed by Rabbi Shmuel Huminer written by an anonymous author, but the introduction hints that the writer is "one of the leading rabbis of these times".
The Steipler writes that the pamphlet is very hurtful to people, "It is now clear that Chassidim who conduct themselves in holiness for several generations are very hurt by this pamphlet and declare that it will harm the peace of their home, G-d forbid, etc.". The Steipler requests that Rabbi Shmuel Huminer bury the pamphlet (in geniza). "If you do not intend to put it in geniza, at least tear out the leaf of introduction, and on Page 7 at the top, erase the words "Letter by one of the leading rabbis of these times", so that the reader will not discern that someone else wrote the pamphlet, but it shall seem as if the publisher edited this letter…".
The polemic regarding the Steipler's opinion on the subject of guiding couples before their marriage on holy conduct of the Jewish home and the comeback of disciples of the Ger Rebbe author of the Beit Yisrael against the publishing of his opinion, is a veiled topic and most of the relevant facts are unknown. Now, this historical letter on this affair has been discovered.
2 leaves, 19.5 cm. Very good condition, folding marks.
Photos of this item are not available.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue
Auction 44 - Judaica: Books, Manuscripts, Rabbinical Letters
March 11, 2015
Opening: $600
Sold for: $1,500
Including buyer's premium
Letter of declaration handwritten and signed by Rabbi Aharon Leib Shteinman on the subject of postponing the enlistment of yeshiva students to the IDF. [Bnei Brak], the 2nd of Elul 1983.
In the letter, Rabbi Shteinman declares: "I will write a permit in regard to the postponing of a student’s enlistment to the army only in the case of a student who occupies himself in nothing else other than his studies in the Yeshiva, and only to somebody for whom the Torah is his sole occupation".
Leaf, 20 cm. good condition. Folding marks.
In the letter, Rabbi Shteinman declares: "I will write a permit in regard to the postponing of a student’s enlistment to the army only in the case of a student who occupies himself in nothing else other than his studies in the Yeshiva, and only to somebody for whom the Torah is his sole occupation".
Leaf, 20 cm. good condition. Folding marks.
Category
Letters Concerning Public Matters, Polemic, Elections and Politics
Catalogue